The Board has long had the authority to adopt “emergency regulation[s]” “to require curtailment of diversions when water is not available under the diverter’s priority of right, or in furtherance of any of the foregoing, to require reporting of diversion or use or the preparation of monitoring reports.”…The Board has utilized its emergency regulation authority to enact regulations authorizing it to curtail water use by classes of water right holders during droughts. Neither section 1058.5 nor any of these regulations contains the limits found in section 1052(a). (citations omitted.)
the court’s decision does not impact the State Water Board’s ongoing drought response actions, including curtailments of senior water rights, which rely on drought emergency regulations. Likewise, it does not impact the board’s authority to take actions against illegal diversions, nor does it preclude the board from taking enforcement measures to protect water released from storage, such as the State Water Project or Central Valley Project.
“Because the Board did not base these notices on the presence (or even possible presence) of stored water in the Delta, the trial court properly concluded that the Board’s authority to act under section 1052(a) could not be upheld on that basis.”
The State Water Board may ultimately have to revise their water unavailability analysis for the Delta watershed to track releases and diversions of SWP and CVP stored water. Currently the Water Board does not collect enough information to do such an analysis.
The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation’s permits for the Central Valley Project require reporting of maximum amounts of stored water rediverted by the Sacramento River Settlement Contractors under Reclamation’s permits, but as we wrote to the Water Board in 2021, Reclamation has yet to fully comply with these terms.
Des Jardins, D. Diversions by Settlement Contractors and CVP Permits, California Water Research blog, June 6, 2021.
State Water Resources Control Board, Water Unavailability Methodology for the Delta Watershed, web page, accessed September 15, 2022.
One thought on “Will ruling on pre-1914 curtailments force the Water Board to track stored water?”
Thank you so much for your succinct review of this extremely important ruling. It’s a bit scary to think of the impact of this case.